So began the saga of Glitter, “a collision of back luck, bad timing, and sabotage,” as Carey would later describe in her extraordinary 2020 memoir, The Meaning of Mariah Carey. Twenty-five years on, the album and film’s mere title conjures a particular kind of pop cultural catastrophe, professional embarrassment, and a brush with career extinction. It remains the quintessential pop star nadir. Oh, and if you weren’t aware, Glitter was also released on 9/11.
The movie is bad. There’s a reason you can only really find it on YouTube, as I did a few weeks ago, watching it with a group of thoroughly beguiled gay guys. The album, however—over which Carey had complete creative control, unlike the film—is very good. At times, it’s great. And in certain places, the soundtrack to Glitter is downright transcendent. The long-awaited deluxe edition, released this October for its 25th anniversary and bringing the music back to streaming, is even better, with a slate of outtakes and cutting room floor demos, live performances, and unmissable remixes from legendary longtime Carey remixer David Morales and contemporary iconoclasts like Channel Tres and Rochelle Jordan. The reissue confirms what devoted Carey fans have long known: hiding in plain sight, beneath the memes and mythology, is an electric, joyful soundtrack of meticulous ’80s funk and R&B, filled with prescient, genre-bending collaborations and covers, and rounded out by a handful of stellar piano ballads. Two of them, at their soul-baring best, even deserve a place alongside “My All” and “I Still Believe” in the Mariah Carey pantheon.
Glitter is hardly Carey’s masterpiece (that distinction belongs, jointly, to Butterfly and The Emancipation of Mimi). It’s better understood as a mixtape, a loose, somewhat haphazardly sequenced collection of homages and collaborations, much of which—with the exception of the ballads and “Loverboy”—likely wouldn’t belong on a studio album. As a film soundtrack it’s even more adrift, lacking any real center of gravity or narrative owing to the emotional black hole at the heart of the movie itself. (It often matters: Soundtrack classics like “Shallow” and “Hard Out Here for a Pimp” work not just because they’re great songs, but because of how deeply imbued they are with the spirit of the films that inspired them.)

